Skip to content Accessibility info

For more than 55 years, Pepper, Johnstone & Company has been trusted with insuring families and businesses. We partner with 60+ insurance companies so that you can consider options that provide the most appropriate protection.

Umbrella insurance provides additional liability coverage that supplements your existing homeowners coverage and auto insurance policy when those liability limits are exceeded. It can provide extra liability protection for eligible claims involving bodily injury, property damage to others, and certain personal liability issues such as false arrest, libel, or defamation. It does not replace car insurance or homeowners insurance; it extends them after a covered claim goes beyond those policy limits. At PJCO Insurance, we help you understand how umbrella coverage can supplement your existing policies and provide broader financial protection. Coverage is subject to policy terms, conditions, exclusions, and limits.

To qualify for umbrella insurance, you generally need to maintain minimum liability limits on your existing auto and homeowners insurance policies. Many insurers require at least $250,000 in auto insurance liability coverage and at least $300,000 in homeowners insurance, though requirements vary by insurance company. At PJCO Insurance, we can review your current policies to help determine whether they meet the eligibility requirements for umbrella coverage, and an insurance representative can confirm your current limits and eligibility. Maintaining the required underlying limits helps ensure your policies work together as intended.

Umbrella insurance is primarily designed to provide additional liability protection rather than cover damage to your own belongings or property, but it may provide coverage when you are legally responsible for damage to someone else's property. For example, it may help protect you financially if a covered claim exceeds the limits of your underlying insurance and additional coverage is needed for third-party property damage, bodily injury, or certain personal liability claims. Damage to your own home, vehicle, or personal possessions generally needs to be addressed through the appropriate property insurance policy. We can help you understand how umbrella insurance fits alongside your existing coverage and identify potential gaps in protection.

Umbrella insurance may be beneficial for individuals and families who want to know how much coverage they need against significant personal risks. It can be particularly worth considering if you own a swimming pool, regularly host guests, have significant assets to protect, have a teen driver in the household, or face increased personal liability exposure. At PJCO Insurance, we help you evaluate your circumstances and existing insurance coverage to determine whether additional liability protection makes sense for you, since multiple factors affect that decision, including your assets, lifestyle, and liability exposure. The right coverage can provide another layer of financial security if a covered claim exceeds your standard policy limits.

Umbrella insurance may cover certain personal injury claims involving libel, slander, or defamation, depending on the policy terms and applicable exclusions. These claims can arise when statements allegedly harm another person's reputation and lead to legal action, legal fees, attorney fees, or a demand for compensation, though coverage for these claims still depends on the policy's terms and exclusions even when the umbrella may respond. At PJCO Insurance, we can explain how personal liability coverage may apply to these situations and help you understand the limitations of your policy. Coverage is not automatic for every claim, so reviewing the policy language is important.

How much does umbrella insurance cost? The appropriate amount of umbrella insurance depends on how much coverage you choose, along with your assets, potential liability exposure, existing insurance limits, and overall financial circumstances. Personal umbrella policies commonly offer coverage beginning at $1 million; the average umbrella insurance cost is about $383 annually for $1 million in coverage, with many policies ranging from $300 to $600 per year, while a $2 million policy averages about $474 annually. Umbrella insurance cost also depends on several factors, including your assets, vehicles, household drivers, and existing underlying policies. At PJCO Insurance, we can help you assess your needs and compare available coverage limits to find an option suited to your circumstances. Choosing an appropriate limit can help provide additional financial protection against covered liability claims that exceed your underlying policy limits.

J.W. E.
on Google

We recently switched our home and auto policies to Pepper, Johnstone & Co and have had a great experience. Their entire team is not only knowledgeable but down to earth and willing to share their time, tips and creative ideas. They’ve helped us to achieve to comprehensive protection at the lowest possible cost. I would recommend Pepper, Johnstone and Co to anyone.

— J.W. E.
Teresa H.
on Google

I am always pleased with the gracious and prompt responses to my insurance inquiries, to my specific insurance needs regarding several policies with Pepper, Johnstone & Company. The staff, especially Lauren Hart, makes every effort to take care of my insurance needs, addressing many concerns. I could not be more pleased and feel more secure knowing these folks are taking care of business for me and in my best interest.

— Teresa H.
Jeremiah H.
on Google

Pepper Johnstone has handled my personal and business insurance needs for years. They do good work and their staff is amazing! They are independent agents so they have access to several different lines of insurance to meet the needs of their clients. I highly recommend them.

— Jeremiah H.
Janet F.
on Google

This is a great company to work with! Casandra did an excellent job making sure my claim was completed in a timely manner. Julie is always there to help me any time I need to make changes to my insurance needs. The staff is always professional to work with. I trust Pepper, Johnstone & Company with all my insurance needs and have for many years.

— Janet F.
Russ L.
on Google

I started a company in January 2019 & the team at Pepper Johnstone helped me from the beginning. We serve mid-cap to large public companies in Alabama, Colorado and Texas. And, Bryan has been critical in helping us meet and maintain the required commercial insurance policies and coverage levels. Key reasons that I've been so pleased primarily include their high level of technical competence and timely responsiveness on new or changing insurance coverage requests. They do a great job & I can highly recommend them.

— Russ L.
Sharon K.
on Google

I have dealt with Pepper Johnstone and company in the past and have always had a good experience. This past week I needed a policy, I called Julie and she efficiently, and promptly quoted and bound coverage on the property. I would highly recommend Pepper Johnstone.

— Sharon K.